Breanna
November 11, 2026
Extremely disappointing experience. I would think twice before purchasing open-box merchandise from Best Buy.
We recently purchased an open-box Insignia television advertised as being in “Good” condition. According to Best Buy’s own condition guidelines, Good condition means the product is fully functional and works like new, with the possibility of missing non-essential parts and accessories.
When we picked up the television, it was missing both the power cord and original remote.
When I questioned this, I was repeatedly told that Best Buy cannot guarantee accessories are included with open-box purchases. However, when I pointed out that their own guidelines specifically refer to missing NON-ESSENTIAL accessories, I asked where the listing disclosed that these components were missing. Nobody could show me.
We eventually purchased a replacement remote from the store, only to discover that it wouldn’t pair with the television. After hours of troubleshooting and contacting Insignia directly, the manufacturer indicated that the television likely had a faulty internal pairing device.
I also asked the store where the documentation was showing that the television had been tested before being sold as fully functional. They couldn’t produce that information either.
We ultimately had to return the television and purchase a brand-new replacement.
What made this experience even worse was the complete lack of accountability or genuine concern from management. Despite multiple phone calls, visits to the store, and hours spent trying to resolve an issue that wasn’t our fault, we were met with repeated explanations of why Best Buy couldn’t help us.
The only goodwill accommodation offered was $25 off our replacement television.
I understand that open-box merchandise comes with certain risks. I don’t expect perfection when purchasing an open-box item. But I do expect accurate product descriptions, reasonable disclosure of missing components, and some level of accountability when a product turns out to be potentially defective.
Instead, we were left doing all the troubleshooting, making multiple trips, spending additional money, and repeatedly advocating for ourselves.
This experience has significantly changed how I view Best Buy as a retailer. We have been customers of theirs for YEARS. The way a company handles a problem says a lot about its customer service, and unfortunately, Best Buy fell very short.
I would strongly encourage anyone considering an open-box purchase to be extremely cautious.
Response from Best Buy
November 11, 2026
Good Afternoon, Breanna,
We fully understand how you are feeling after your open box TV was missing unexpected accessories. We would be happy to review this further with you. Please feel free to send us a private message on social media that includes your Google review case ID: #253598.
- Facebook (https://bby.me/SXcchE)
- Twitter/X (https://bby.me/22JEbB)
- Instagram (https://bby.me/wYK2Xz)
Be careful purchasing appliances from Best Buy Joliet. If I could give a 0 I would. I went into the store and bought a refigerator. They brought it to my house I opened it up the door and it was dirty, had butter in it and was scratched. It was definitely used! I called right away they said you want us to replace it with a new one right. Ummm yes I didn't pay for a used one. They scheduled a delivery for my new refigerator today Saturday. I never get a text nothing so I called yesterday Friday to confirm. They said yes it will arrive Saturday between 2-4 pm. I never get a text nothing. So I checked on line and it says now it will be delivered Monday so of course I called they said oh im sorry I don't know what happened but now its scheduled for Monday. Not only did you bring me a used refigerator but now the delivery is bring pushed back 2 days!!!!This has been the worse experience i have ever had. I will never order again from here !
Best buy is my greatest shopping company, a very incredible shop for all appliances and many more. I love to go there always.
I had an extremely disappointing experience at the Joliet Best Buy while attempting to trade in my Nintendo Switch 1 toward a Nintendo Switch 2. I was expecting to receive the $150 trade-in offer, but what should have been a straightforward transaction turned into an unnecessarily frustrating and disrespectful interaction with an employee named Aannar.
From the very beginning, Aannar was rude and unprofessional. He explained that my version of the Nintendo Switch, which is the newest version of the original Switch, was not showing up in their system. Rather than making an effort to help resolve the issue, he blamed Best Buy's computers, stating that they never update their systems. He then told me to simply purchase the Switch 2 online and wait an hour to get it.
What made this experience particularly frustrating was the way Aannar communicated with me. He repeatedly interrupted me, even saying, "Let me interrupt you." I should not have to ask an employee to allow me to finish a sentence before speaking over me. When I asked him to stop interrupting me, he continued speaking in a raised voice. His attitude and tone were completely inappropriate for someone working in customer service.
Customers deserve to be treated with basic courtesy and respect, even when a system issue or transaction problem arises. I was there to make a purchase and complete a trade-in, not to argue with an employee who seemed unwilling to listen or provide helpful assistance.
After leaving the Joliet location, I went to another Best Buy. During that visit, I was told that my experience was consistent with what others had encountered at the Joliet location, and that many customers choose to visit other locations to receive better service. Hearing that made the experience even more disappointing.
Best Buy is a major retailer, and customers should be able to expect professional, respectful service regardless of which location they visit. Unfortunately, my experience at the Joliet store fell far below that standard.
I hope management takes this feedback seriously, addresses the customer service concerns, and ensures employees are held accountable for how they communicate with customers. No customer should have to deal with repeated interruptions, a raised voice, and a dismissive attitude when simply trying to complete a trade-in.
Response from Best Buy
November 01, 2026
Hello!
Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We strive to provide excellent customer service, and we recognize that this was not the experience you had when attempting to trade in your Nintendo Switch. Please send us a direct message through one of our social media channels, so we can look into this further and assist you. Be sure to mention Google Review 246914 in your message.
Instagram (https://bby.me/CqTm9Y), X/Twitter (https://bby.me/P1tlZt) or Facebook (https://bby.me/El7d7L)