To be fair, I'm going to start this review with the fact I normally ONLY shop at the Apple Glen location, but due to a recent injury, and surgery I was stuck in a wheelchair and this location was closer. KUDOS to Ben and the Geek Squad Staff who were patient, sympathetic and very kind to me while I stood in the store, broken, in pain and crying real tears of frustration. I felt bad for them because their hands were tied with Corporate Red Tape, unfortunately.
I bought a brand-new HP OmniStudio X All-in-One Desktop on BestBuy.com as a paying Total member, with my Best Buy credit card after researching the exact model I wanted to purchase, and after the Best Buy staff informed me they did not have it in stock, directed me to the website to complete my purchase. It was then shipped to my home while I was working and out of town. Upon our return home, we decided to unbox it and the monitor we bought on the same day, same online order. On first assembly, less than a month after delivery, the stand’s locking clip failed, the display fell, and the screen was destroyed. We took it to Northcrest Geek Squad the next morning, the Geek Squad technicians assessed it informed us it was due to a defective mounting clip that could not support the weight of the very large, very heavy computer screen. Best Buy then notified me they could NOT return, refund, nor repair the item because it was a "3rd party vendor," (XTI, Inc), who sold it to me, NOT Best Buy!!!!???? They informed me I would have to deal with the 3rd party vendor, XTI, Inc. to settle the return. Not sure why WE have to deal with a THIRD PARTY we DID NOT BUY FROM, when we are BUYING from a BEST BUY WEBSITE? Regardless, I attempted the return with 3rd party who REFUSED TWICE, and then shifted the blame to HP and told me to file under their warranty. I was then forced to waste more time contacting HP to try to resolve the issue and get a replacement. It sounded hopeful at first, we sent everything over, and their own records state the clip “failed structurally,” yet HP will not honor its warranty because it was an "accidental drop and fall." BUT-FOR THEIR defective part, it would NOT be broken. They sent me back to Best Buy. So I went back to Best Buy again and left the computer with them so they could go higher up the Corporate Chain. I filed a BBB claim and they are still refusing to replace or repair a BRAND NEW computer they sold with a defective part even after I sent XTI and Best Buy a Legal Written "Notice of Revocation of Acceptance and Notice of Breach" due to sale of defective merchandise, requesting a refund or replacement. Which both Best Buy AND XTI, Inc REFUSE to honor. HIDDEN MARKETPLACE WARNING: Best Buy did not clearly disclose or provide any WARNING at checkout that this was a third-party purchase NOR did they disclose or provide any warning this purchase would NOT QUALIFY for the Extended Warranty or Best Buy Total Protection Warranty I paid for which covers purchases and extends a return window to 60-days. My receipt shows only Best Buy’s name. The company clearly knew this was an issue because shortly after this purchase, Best Buy sent me an email notifying me they were extending the Total Protection to Marketplace items. I received the email TWO (2) days before my computer failed, yet since my BBB complaint, Corporate still has not offered a replacement or refund. I have also filed with the Indiana Attorney General, the Federal Trade Commission, and CFPB. This purchase was made on BEST BUY'S website, the invoice only had BEST BUY's name on it, had NO reference to third party vendors, had NO warnings and did not disclose my extended protection policy would NOT cover this. Best Buy will not stand on the products they sell on their website. BEWARE!
Response from Best Buy
November 06, 2026
Hi, Barbara,
Thank you for your review. It can be frustrating when you aren't able to get the assistance that you're wanting when a product is defective. Best Buy has third party sellers on their website. If customers purchase a third party item from our Marketplace sellers, then the manufacturing warranty and support is through the manufacturer. Had the computer been purchased through Best Buy, if it's a factory defect, we would also provide you the manufacturing warranty information to use with the manufacturer. Best Buy is not contracted by the manufacturer to process their manufacturing warranty.
All Marketplace sellers are listed on the product page underneath the product title in bold blue letters. It will say "Sold by Best Buy" or other company name. You can also filter out any search for just Best Buy products using the filter options on the left side of your screen on the website. We began selling Marketplace items earlier this year to provide customers more product options.
If you are in need of assistance in learning how to filter our website to exclude Marketplace sellers or want to formally document your concerns, please send us a private message on social media. Please include Google Review 249432 when reaching out.
Facebook: @BestBuy
Instagram: @BestBuy
Twitter/X: @BestBuySupport