Worst Experience – Misleading “Total Protection” and Zero Accountability
I’ve been a loyal Best Buy customer for over 12 years, consistently purchasing their Total Protection on almost every product because I believed it actually protected my investment. Unfortunately, this experience has completely broken that trust.
In November 2024, I made a purchase and no one informed me that my Total Protection plan was about to expire. I was supposedly meant to receive an email notification — I never did. I even spoke with customer service around that time, and again, nothing was mentioned. No warning, no transparency, no accountability.
Fast forward: I later went into the store and was told my protection had already expired. The solution? “Just renew it.” So I did — trusting their guidance. What they failed to clearly explain is that renewing does not reinstate coverage on previously purchased items.
Now, when I try to file a claim related to an installation issue with a cooktop, I’m being told those items are no longer covered because the protection lapsed — even though they were purchased while the protection plan was active.
That is completely unacceptable.
If I bought products while I had an active protection plan, those items should remain covered for the full term promised (3–4 years), regardless of whether I renew later. Otherwise, what exactly was I paying for? This feels misleading at best and extremely deceptive at worst.
There was:
No proper notification
No clear explanation of consequences
No effort to protect a long-time customer
Instead, I’m left with a worthless “protection” plan that doesn’t actually protect the products it was sold for.
After over a decade of loyalty, this is how customers are treated? Extremely disappointing. I will seriously reconsider doing any future business here
Amazing service from Geek Squad and Lucus on the sales floor.
Frustrating Pokémon TCG purchase limits and inconsistent family treatment at Cedar Park Best Buy
We visited the Best Buy at 11066 Pecan Park Blvd Suite 301 in Cedar Park, TX today (March 27, 2026) with my wife and kid to buy some Pokémon Trading Card Game products. At checkout, the employee asked for my phone number to check my account. They told me I had purchased Pokémon product from another Best Buy location and that I could not buy anything here today — even though I had not made any purchases at this store or today.
The manager on duty, Darik, spoke with us and confirmed we could not purchase. Their policy was explained as one Pokémon item per SKU per person per day per store, but it seems to be tracked and enforced across the entire Best Buy chain through customer accounts.
My wife was allowed to make her purchase using her separate account, but my son and I were completely blocked from buying even one item. I understand the intent is to stop scalpers, but this felt overly strict and unfair for a family shopping together. My child was excited about getting something small and ended up leaving disappointed.
Best Buy should provide clearer communication about how these account-based, cross-store limits work and show more flexibility for legitimate family purchases. Better signage or explanations at the store would also help. We’ll likely look elsewhere for future Pokémon releases.
Response from Best Buy
March 27, 2026
Chris,
Taking a family trip to Best Buy for Pokémon cards should be a fun and exciting trip. Hearing that only your wife was able to purchase is indeed frustrating. We can understand how this has made you feel and invite you to send a private message to Facebook (https://bby.me/8J4Dbq), Twitter/X (https://bby.me/vA8smP), or Instagram (https://bby.me/mcTp2G) so that we can assist. When doing so, please mention that you are responding to Google Review 135477.