Kit from geek squad was incredibly professional and helpful in regards to a phone issue!!
1 Star – Best Buy Doesn't Stand Behind Its Commitments or Its Customers
This was one of the worst customer service experiences I've had with a major retailer.
I ordered a birthday gift for my wife on July 29 based on Best Buy's promise that it would be available for in-store pickup on August 5. The order was split into two shipments. One item arrived on July 31 without issue. The second—and most important—item never made it to the store.
On August 5, after the promised pickup date had already passed, I called customer service and was simply told the store didn't have it and to "check back in a few days."
When I called back a few days later, it had become obvious the gift would not arrive in time for my wife's birthday. I tried repeatedly to work with Best Buy to find a reasonable solution. I wasn't asking for anything outrageous—I simply asked them to help fix a problem that their failure created. Because they missed their promised pickup date, the July sale had ended, and buying the exact same product elsewhere would now cost me over $100 more.
Instead of helping, the first representative, Rohith (Case #378978118), repeatedly gave me false information.
He flat-out told me that no other retailer had the product available, despite the fact I was looking at multiple retailers with inventory while we were on the phone. He then tried to blame the third-party company that delivered the first part of my order, telling me I should contact them to find out why the store never received the second item. That explanation wasn't just unhelpful—it was completely illogical. A third-party company delivering one package to my home has absolutely nothing to do with Best Buy's internal inventory or its ability to fulfill an in-store pickup order.
At that point, it became obvious he was either making things up or simply saying whatever he thought would get me off the phone.
I hung up and called back.
I spoke with Krishna, who escalated me to a supervisor, another Rohith (Case #378980855). Ironically, they both admitted the first representative had provided incorrect information and suggested he may have been new or panicked.
I even proposed a solution myself. The store had version that was one model year newer of the product in stock—unfortunately also in a smaller size—for roughly $50 more. Since I had already spent over $500, I asked if Best Buy would simply cover the price difference so I could at least leave with a comparable product instead of having to spend over $100 more elsewhere because Best Buy failed to honor its own promised pickup date.
The answer?
No.
No accommodation.
No price adjustment.
No substitute.
No expedited resolution.
No ownership.
Just a shrug and an attitude that I could either pay more because of their mistake or wait indefinitely.
Shipping delays happen. Inventory mistakes happen. What separates a good company from a bad one is how they respond afterward. Even after acknowledging they had failed to deliver on their commitment and that their own representative had provided incorrect information, they still refused to do anything to make the situation right.
Apparently, when Best Buy fails to meet its own commitments, that's considered the customer's problem.
Best Buy's response was to provide inaccurate information, shift blame, refuse every reasonable compromise, and leave a customer paying more because of their mistake.
The delay isn't why I'm leaving one star.
The misinformation, refusal to take responsibility, and complete unwillingness to stand behind their own commitments are.
If your purchase has a deadline—a birthday, anniversary, holiday, or any event that actually matters—I would strongly recommend buying from a retailer that either honors its commitments or, at the very least, is willing to make things right when it fails to keep them.
I personally will not be shopping at Best Buy again, and based on this experience, I cannot recommend that anyone else do so either.
Response from Best Buy
August 07, 2026
We understand the frustration of this experience, and appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.
Our team would like to review this further and see what assistance we may offer. Please reach out to us in a private message on Facebook (https://bby.me/GE8lSA), Twitter/X (https://bby.me/Dxynmi), or Instagram (https://bby.me/yihaiW), and mention your Google review, 199767.
Alfred was amazing and knowledgeable about helping me upgrade my laptop!
Viktoriia F
August 02, 2026
I haven’t experienced customer service this good in a long time! A huge thank you to Ralph for helping us choose exactly what we needed. He made the whole process quick and easy, and even helped us carry everything out. Truly outstanding service! We need more salespeople like Ralph. Thanks 🙌